I was never able to compare the two. I have Borresen speakers and ended up getting an Axxess Forte 2. I am tired of separate components and the costs that come with them. I love the Forte 2 and I plan on moving up to the Aavik U-188 when they start hitting the used market. I don’t think the P1 is better than my Forte and I felt the Lumin app was quirky. Hope this helps.
Todd