Jazz for aficionados


Jazz for aficionados

I'm going to review records in my collection, and you'll be able to decide if they're worthy of your collection. These records are what I consider "must haves" for any jazz aficionado, and would be found in their collections. I wont review any record that's not on CD, nor will I review any record if the CD is markedly inferior. Fortunately, I only found 1 case where the CD was markedly inferior to the record.

Our first album is "Moanin" by Art Blakey and The Jazz Messengers. We have Lee Morgan , trumpet; Benney Golson, tenor sax; Bobby Timmons, piano; Jymie merrit, bass; Art Blakey, drums.

The title tune "Moanin" is by Bobby Timmons, it conveys the emotion of the title like no other tune I've ever heard, even better than any words could ever convey. This music pictures a person whose down to his last nickel, and all he can do is "moan".

"Along Came Betty" is a tune by Benny Golson, it reminds me of a Betty I once knew. She was gorgeous with a jazzy personality, and she moved smooth and easy, just like this tune. Somebody find me a time machine! Maybe you knew a Betty.

While the rest of the music is just fine, those are my favorite tunes. Why don't you share your, "must have" jazz albums with us.

Enjoy the music.
orpheus10

Showing 50 responses by pjw81563

Being a native New Yorker I tuned in to watch the NY Mets play the NY Yankees in a baseball game tonight.

Since today is the 20th year to the day of the terrorist attacks on my home country the NYPD and FDNY are being honored on the field before the game.

But what struck me the most was the young jazz vocalist sensation  Anais Reno who sand our National Anthem. I had never heard of her or listened to her beautiful voice until tonight.

I immediately went to Amazon and ordered this talented (and beautiful) young ladies debut album released this past March and titled " Lovesome Thing"

Lovesome Thing features Anias singing the following great songs from the American Jazz Standards.

Caravan; Mood Indigo; Still in Love; Chelsea Bridge / A Flower is a Lovesome Thing; I'm Just a Lucky So-and- So; It's Kind of Lonesome Tonight; Day Dream; I Ain't Got Nothing but the Blues; All Roads Lead Back to You; U.M.M.G. (Upper Manhattan Medical Group); Lush Life; Take the "A" Train.

Anaïs Reno (anaisreno.com)

(2) Benny Benack III & Anais Reno - Caravan - YouTube

(2) Lush Life - YouTube

(2) Anais Reno, It's kind of lonesome out tonight, Duke Ellington - YouTube


OK this weekend I listened to discs 5 through 8 of the LEE MORGAN COMPLETE 8 CD LIVE AT THE LIGHTHOUSE.

All 8 discs are excellent remasters. Sonics are second to non as far as the digital (CD) versions are concerned.

What I noticed the most was how night after night Lee Morgan had Bennie Maupin lead off on the solo's. 
Many of the tracks Lee and Bennie played note for note together.

Lee was obviously recovered from his heroin addiction and sounded fantastic.

Its a shame his GF killed him.
Burton, Corea, Metheny, Haynes, Holland - "Question and Answer"
That is the first song on the Quintet album titled "Like Minds"

There is a trio album titled Question and Answer with 3 of the 5 artists on the Like Minds album.

Question And Answer | Discogs

I have both discs and both are really good albums in their entirety. Keegiam I suggest you check out the trio if you have not yet.
So sorry to learn this.  One of my favorites. This came immediately to mind:
Mraz will be missed

You have posted Urban Dreams from Pepper Adams a few times over the years and I think it is very good album so I always meant to own a copy but then would forget over time. I'm on my way to Discogs now to order a copy so I dont forget again.

Thanks for posting it again.
Anyone who thinks he is not a Jazz player of the highest order is just not listening
Tales From The Hudson was, IMHO, Michael Brecker's  best album. I purchased it after buying a few of his earlier sessions as a leader and many more as a sideman or co leader/collaborator.

And yes Metheny is a great jazz guitarist - on that album. Anyone who thinks Metheny is not one of the best ever on the instrument is in denial. 

Where it gets blurred is that Metheny, on all of his own projects and collaborations with Lyle Mays I really can't call it jazz. I have listened to Metheny play straight ahead jazz often, on TFTH and other sessions where he plays in the traditional jazz harmonies like Montgomery or Martino.

I would call Metheny's projects "creative guitar music"

As in 

(7) PAT METHENY & LYLE MAYS ~ SEPTEMBER FIFTEENTH -
 YouTube


Its when Metheny collaborates with someone other then Lyle Mays that he sound more "jazz like"

As in

(7) Jazzfest Berlin 1990 - (III) - Pat Metheny Trio - Dave Holland (b) - Roy Haynes (dr) deel 1.avi - YouTube

And here is an example of Metheny jamming like a "hard rocker" fast forward to 4:10

(7) Pat Metheny & Anna Maria Jopek-Are you going with me? - YouTube

Do I think Pat Metheny is a guitar virtuoso - yes, do I think his albums with Lyle Mays (the bulk of his own art) sound like jazz..no



New York City (WABC)

Pat Metheny's music is so diverse that he is the only artist ever to have won a dozen Grammy Awards in a dozen different categories, and his latest record features some of New York City's most talented young musicians.

Excellent 3 minute video on Metheny here:

Grammy winner Pat Metheny talks about new album and its influence (msn.com)

Bror Fredrik "Esbjörn" Svensson (16 April 1964 – 14 June 2008) was a Swedish jazz pianist and founder of the jazz group  Esbjörn Svensson Trio, commonly known as e.s.t.

Svensson became one of Europe's most successful jazz musicians at the turn of the 21st century before dying, at the age of 44, in a scuba diving accident.

Swedish Guitarist extraordinaire Ulf Wakenius created a tribute album in memory of the pianist  Bror Fredrik "Esbjörn" Svensson after his untimely death in 2008. 

Love Is Real by Ulf Wakenius:

(9) Believe Beleft Below - YouTube



Hello pryso its been a while.

Yes its a short video but full of great remembrances by McGlaughlin.

Hendrix drummer Mitch Mitchell was a huge fan of Toney Williams.

John McGlaughlin and Mitch Mitchell were once in the same band together.

One night after doing a show at the Village Vanguard Mitch Michell invited John and organist Larry Young and bassist Dave Holland to come with him around the corner to Electric Ladyland Studios for a jam session with Jimi.

Mcglaughlin was playing a hollow body electric guitar at the time.

Mcglaughlin met Hendrix drummer Buddy Miles from Hendrix's Band Of Gypsies group that night and Buddy brought John to one of Hendrix's live performances at Madison Square Garden.

Thank you...

I focus my energy to bought many of his albums.... He was unknown to me.... I like european jazz but particularly nordic jazz very much
Happy to help. I like the trio as well. Are you familiar with guitarist Terje Rypdal, drummer Jon Christensen, bassist Arild Anderson and brass/reed man Jan Garbarek?

(9) Terje Rypdal / Victor Bailey / Billy Cobham - Jazz festival Viersen 1994-09-17 (Full Concert) - YouTube

(9) Jon Christensen: The Lyrical Drum Solo - YouTube

All four performing Afric Pepperbird (A song from a Garbarek album of the same name)

(9) Jan Garbarek Quartet - Bremerhaven - 26 Sep 1971 - YouTube

Afric Pepperbird - Wikipedia




Keith Jarrett in Oslo 1974 brings a more soothing harmonies to meld with Garbarek's typically experimental (avant garde) creativity.

(9) Keith Jarrett, Jan Garbarek & "Nordic Quartet" Oslo 1974 (NRK TV-studio) - YouTube
I have around 100 albums recorded on the ECM label. I know Paul Bley has been a topic recently here and this live album that Bley, along with Gary Peacock and Paul Motian recorded for ECM definitely is in my top 10 ECM favorites department.

(9) When Will The Blues Leave (Live at Aula Magna STS, Lugano-Trevano / 1999) - YouTube
mahgister I have been listening to a lot of the Scandinavian musicians, old and new, over this past summer.

All of them, old and new, are extremely talented and diverse musicians.

Garbarek and his 4 bandmates I listed that played with him on the 1970 album titled Afric Pepperbird recorded the majority of their music on the ECM label.

ECM, since its inception in 1969, has welcomed the majority of jazz artists that are, shall we say, a breed apart. The music these artists create simply cannot be called "jazz"

The music on ECM label releases has been called many things.

avant garde, diverse, world, improv, and free are 5 words that have been used but I myself prefer the word "creative"

Please post your favorite creative Scandinavian artists songs. I always enjoy new music that I am unfamiliar with.

EST’s "When Everyone Has Gone" is one of my favorites. This one also gets repeated listening sessions:

(9) Esbjörn Svensson Trio Plays Monk - YouTube

Hello frog hope all is well. I listened to the whole Bob Mintzer WDR (yes all 34 minutes) and really enjoyed it. And yes, that trombone solo 2:30-4:30 is played beautifully. Thanks for that.

Yesterday while driving and listening to my pandora jazz stations on my blue tooth headphones I heard for the first time (was not aware of this session) Oscar Peterson + one. The "one" being Clark Terry on flugelhorn, trumpet and vocals. It was a beautiful tune that I like so much I noted the LP cover photo and searched for a cd copy on discogs.

Here is a couple tunes from the session

(23) Brotherhood Of Man - YouTube

 

Been posting on JFA for 4 years now and everyone know how I feel about Buddy Rich. To my ears he is the best big band drummer I have ever heard.... Its like boxing which I love just as much as jazz. Its no coincidence that the golden age of jazz - 1935 through 1965 - was also the golden age of boxing.

The great American journalist A.J. Liebling who wrote one of the best all time pugilistic books titled "THE SWEET SCIENCE" wrote in the book 3 words that have been re- written by other authors and has been repeated in millions of conversations about boxing since the beginning of the sport known as SWEET SCIENCE.

Those 3 words are STYLES MAKE FIGHTS.

It is my opinion the STYLES MAKE MUSIC. and Buddy had style - a truck load of style. The unmistakable style that propelled many a big band. Just a few favorites of mine:

(10) Buddy Rich with Tommy Dorsey & his Orchestra 1943 "Well Git It" - YouTube

(10) Buddy Rich - Mercy Mercy Mercy Live (1968) - YouTube

(10) Buddy Rich Big Band - Big Swing Face - YouTube

Buddy detractors say he is not capable of holding back with a light touch - keeping the swing propelling without overpowering the other musicians. Well I give you this small band with Lester Young, Nat King Cole, and Buddy.

(10) SOMEBODY LOVES ME by Lester Young, Nat King Cole and Buddy Rich - YouTube





Frogman I’M sure you are aware that the United States of America was very, very different back in those days compared to 1965 through 2021.

The 40’s generation was known as "The Greatest Generation". Numerous books have been written on the subject. The reasons given for why "The Greatest Generation" are the very same reasons that made artists the most creative, uplifting, courageous, sincere, unselfish, and most of all hard working and willing to sacrifice humans. I just named some and there is more. Don’t get me started on the Second World War - there is not enough space.

Its not a coincidence the artists - which musicians and boxers both are - share all of these words that define "The Greatest Generation"





**** Its no coincidence that the golden age of jazz - 1935 through 1965 - was also the golden age of boxing. ****
Just as there were the most recognized and dominate pugilists during that period the same hold true for jazz wouldn't you agree?

You know the jazz greats who performed during that 30 year period frogman so I'll just name a few boxers as this is a jazz forum and though I would love to talk boxing for hours I have other avenues for that.

Archie Moore called the mongoose, was the greatest Light Heavyweight of all time had his first professional fight in 1935 and his last in 1963
Moore fought in 4 different decades compiling a record of and retired with 186 wins - 132 by knockout with just 23 losses. Archie loved jazz and was very good friends with Lucky Thompson who used to play his sax while Archie trained.

Joe Louis, arguably the greatest heavyweight of all time fought from 1934 - 1951  Louis is widely regarded as one of the greatest and most influential boxers of all time. He reigned as the world heavyweight champion from 1937 until his temporary retirement in 1949. He was victorious in 25 consecutive title defenses, a record for all weight classes. Louis had the longest single reign as champion of any boxer in history.

Sugar Ray Robinson fought from 1940 - 1965. Ray had 174 wins - 109 by knockout with only 19 losses. Ray turned professional in 1940 at the age of 19 and by 1951 had a professional record of 128–1–2 with 84 knockouts. From 1943 to 1951 Robinson went on a 91-fight unbeaten streak, the third-longest in professional boxing history. Robinson held the world welterweight title from 1946 to 1951, and won the world middleweight title in the latter year. Ray was great friends with Miles Davis and it was  at Ray's urging that Davis kicked his heroin habit in 1953.

Rocky Marciano also fought during these years. Marciano became the Heavyweight Champion in 1952 and defended his belt until 1956 when he retired undefeated at 49 - 0 with 43 knockouts.



Black Americans is the answer. As their employment / career opportunities increased across the society, the number of them wanting to Box or be Jazz musicians decreased. There have probably been many potentially as good as Ali, Louis and  Marciano etc ... they are just working in cooperate America. Or maybe in the NBA, NFL or MLB.  All a lot easier than boxing or trying to earn a living in Jazz.

Other groups, Irish, Jews, Italians etc... traveled the same journey.
Thanks roc for an alternate yet just as true statement as the explanations I tried to bring forward


I disagree. Some folks ( ne'er-do-wells ), will ALWAYS be on the journey, no matter what the situation is.  Including a lot of white folks.


I agree true indeed. Always has, is , and will be the lazy ones.
I like japan jazz performers...

But your link dont work i think....

Could you refresh it? Thanks...

I am curious.....
The link did not work for me as well. I do not own a lot of Japanese musician discs. The ones I do have I really like.

Pianist Ryo Fukui is one of the older artists I listen to. Sadly Fukui passed in 2016 and in his 40 years on the jazz scene recorded only 5 studio albums as far as I know.

(11) Ryo Fukui - Scenery 1976 (FULL ALBUM) - YouTube

(11) Ryo Fukui - Mellow Dream [Full Album, 1977] - YouTube

(11) Ryo Fukui - Ryo Fukui In New York (1999) FULL ALBUM [4K - 5.1] - YouTube

Pianist Hiromi Uehara is a newer artist that released her first album in 2002 titled "Another Mind" and since that released another dozen albums all of them, IMHO, very good. Hiromi’s 2008 album "Beyond Standard" is my favorite. I have seen her live a couple times at the Blue Note NYC and her energized playing and the joy and happiness in brings her always spills out into the crowd which gave her a very loud standing applause at the end of both of the shows I attended. I own all of her albums. Half of them on SACD hybrid format.

(11) Softly As In A Morning Sunrise - YouTube

(11) Hiromi’s Sonicbloom - Time Out - YouTube

(11) Hiromi The Trio Project performing "Alive" (Live in the Studio) - YouTube
Art Farmer, featuring Jim Hall 'To sweden with love' album from 1964
Sweden folk songs played in jazz mode
Hello Alek hope you are well.

Those Swedish songs are played very well by those 2 American jazz giants. 
(11) Farmer's Market - Art Farmer - YouTube

(11) Art Farmer - Modern Art - YouTube

(11) My Funny Valentine - Bill Evans & Jim Hall - YouTube

(11) Darn That Dream - Bill Evans & Jim Hall - YouTube

The lack of historical and sociological perspective on display here from time to time is disconcerting.
Yes, if you dont understand this is a good answer.

Keep the music coming, folks
Then why did you not post music. I have been all along. Look above and below.

(12) Duran (Take 4) - YouTube

(12) Sugar Ray - YouTube

(12) Archie Moore - YouTube

(12) Right Off - Miles Davis - YouTube

Listening to Roy Eldridge a lot lately. I just bought The Complete Verve Roy Eldridge Studio Sessions 7 × CD, Compilation, Stereo, Mono
Box Set, Limited Edition, Numbered

(14) Yard Dog - YouTube

(14) Let Me Off Uptown - YouTube

(14) Roy Eldridge Blue Moon - YouTube

Dr. Lonnie Smith was such a great live act. NEA Jazz Master 2017.
George Benson and Lonnie formed Bensons Quartet in 1966 and recorded ITS UPTOWN.  Lonnie was a great live act. I'm going to miss him.

With George Benson 1966
(14) George Benson - Bullfight (1966) - YouTube

Live at Club Mozambique
(14) I Can't Stand It (Live At Club Mozambique, Detroit, 1970) - YouTube

From BREATH - Lonnie's last album released on the Blue Note label January 2021:
(14) Why Can't We Live Together - YouTube


Could not find this album that I have on ytube, so I will post it this way.
If I would know how, would upload it myself.
Hello Alek. Happy your ok and thanks for posting the Dr. Lonnie Smith and his 3 Japanese friends who recorded that "LIVE JAM" -THE JAZZ FUNK MASTERS. 

It was recorded  live in Tokyo at the club Jirokichi and released on a Japanese label called P VINE records on LP and CD the same year.

It has never been reissued. 

The 5 live songs are typical Lonnie Smith funk and gospel "boogie" music. I liked all of the songs.

Dr. Lonnie Smiths music is never dull. I saw him live a half dozen times in NYC and I was never disappointed. He was quite the showman on the Hammond B 3. 


Marvelous musical social commentary, PJW.
thanks OP hope all is well with you.
acman that Charlie Parker 1953 Montreal is a gem.

Personnel: Charlie Parker (alto sax, except 2), Brew Moore (tenor sax, -2,4), Paul Bley (piano), Dick Garcia (guitar), Neil Michaud (bass), Ted Paskert (drums)

 I had to look up Brew Moore and saw this

 "When I heard what Bird had done for himself, I realized that Pres was not the complete messiah. So I combined Bird and Pres and my own thing."

   "with fellow tenors Stan Getz, Al Cohn, Zoot Sims, and Alan Eager; at the time, they all sounded identical. Moore was the only one of the five who did not change his sound through the years."
This is the most remarkable thing in music I have ever seen !

Remember that boys name    Nicolò Pellegrino
I wont forget it
Thanks acman for that Earl Harvin Trio clip.

 Dave Palmer is masterful on the electric Fender Rhodes.
Pjw, one of my desert island disk. Saw them at the Gypsy Tea Room.
Also saw an early Wilco show there.
In Dallas Texas?

I know it seems like a dumb question but there are many, restaurants and pubs in America, and I am sure globally, named "The Gypsy Tea Room". We have one in NYC...
re-lar-kvothe Love jazz of all kinds but the fusion of the 70s influenced me over all else.
Great 70s fusion selections from both you and our esteemed OP.

Great Ray Charles songs and discussion.

Still listening to it all and I am happy the petty arguments have faded away.

This ones for the last true jazz aficionado here on JFA

(8) Take the "A" Train with solo by Elvin Jones - Duke Ellington - YouTube

(8) Louis Armstrong - Basin Street Blues - YouTube
Here we go again......

Ok I will try my best to help out with this ongoing trivial distraction which only takes away from the mostly positive experience of JFA.

First and foremost since when are jazz aficionados not allowed to have a difference of opinions. This is not 1938 Nazi Germany is it?????

That said I will attempt a resolution and address our OP first. I know you are a big Lee Morgan fan and aficionado of his talented trumpet playing. I agree that on the studio album Art Blakey And The Jazz Messengers A Night In Tunisia here:   Acoustic Sounds Lee Morgan hits the high registers quite often and sounds great doing it. However it is highly possible that on the live version Morgan could have been  doped up, a little drunk, maybe a combination of both, maybe hungover or in need of a "fix" or maybe he was just plain exhausted that particular night. Any of the reasons I have stated could have effected his playing on his solo - THAT PARTICULAR RENDITION RECORDED LIVE THAT NIGHT.

frogman the studio solos on a lot of jazz albums are improvised just as in a live setting. Also live recording equipment in those days was sub par and may effect the end result. The reasons I gave O10 above certainly could have an effect on a musician. So yes your opinion that Morgan was unusually playing in the high register on that live recording and on THAT PARTICULAR RECORDING THAT NIGHT sounded "off" is not without merit.

YOU BOTH HAVE GOOD POINTS AND I RESPECT BOTH OPINIONS

Can we get back to posting JFA???????????
frogman that 1959 complete set 1 from Art Blakey And The Jazz Messengers in Paris is a gem. Thanks for sharing.

Morgan was 21 and Shorter 26. I count myself lucky to have seen Wayne Shorter live for his 80th birthday anniversary tour at NYC Town Hall.

I have about 15 each of Morgan and Shorter as leaders and everything from their stints, live and studio, with Blakey as I am a "Art Blakey completist"

You and Mahgister have expressed all that I hear when listening to those two great musicians and so I only want to say if you can get a chance to watch this video please do so. I highly recommend it.

Watch I Called Him Morgan | Prime Video (amazon.com)
Here you are, all alleged Aficionados, talking about the best Trumpet player, and NO ONE has even mentioned Armstrong!!!  Sad state of affairs. Sad.
roc I posted Satchmo and the Duke about 12 posts before yours on the same page. You must have missed it.

Does that get me off of your "alleged JA" list?
 But Wayne was also independently churning out masterpieces like JuJu, Et Cetera, and Speak No Evil, and we'll be forever better off for it. Mesmerizing, exotic, intoxicating, essential.
keegiam Wayne Shorter never had a bad album as a leader. Even in the 70's, 80's and right up to his last release "Emanon" 

A great book to read. I did and I highly recommend.

Footprints: The Life and Work of Wayne Shorter: Mercer, Michelle: 9781585424689: Amazon.com: Books
mahgister

And i love trumpeters like i love pianists....


The trumpet is probably the most "symbolic" instrument when it come to jazz genre. I agree with you and will never call one trumpeter "the best"

But as you also said we all have our favorites and I would like to mention a few of mine

Roy Eldridge, Dizzy Gillespie, Louis Armstrong, Freddie Hubbard, Miles Davis, Chet Baker and Lee Morgan - not necessarily in that order.

I do admit though, to being a Clifford Brown completist. I would also say he is my most favorite by just a hair over the others.

I also really like Kenny Dorham.

As we aficionados all know, Clifford Brown was an up and coming star in the jazz world and a young phenom on the trumpet when he tragically died in a car accident at age 25 in 1956.  Brown won the DownBeat magazine Critics' Poll for New Star of the Year in 1954.

   Kenny Dorham's talent is frequently lauded by critics and other musicians, but he never received the kind of attention or public recognition from the jazz establishment that many of his peers did. For this reason, Dorham's name has become "virtually synonymous with underrated."

I am wishing the 6 songs I chose to represent both of these exceptional artists are acceptable selections to show off their respective virtuosity, and most of all the distinctive sound of each of them. I think the two of them made Louis Armstrong proud.

Clifford

(10) Art Blakey & Clifford Brown - 1954 - A Night At Birdland Vol1 - 05 A Night In Tunisia - YouTube

(10) Clifford Brown & Max Roach - Study In Brown ( Full Album ) - YouTube

(10) Clifford Brown & Max Roach - Jordu - YouTube

Kenny

(10) Kenny Dorham - 1961 - Whistle Stop - 04 - Whistle Stop - YouTube

(10) Kenny Dorham - Una mas - YouTube

(10) Manhã de Carnaval (Live) - YouTube