Day three impressions:
Last night I tried something interesting. I had just received a copy of the newly issued Bob Dylan Love and Theft, MoFi 2LP 45 RPM release. I played it through on my analog system, and while I listened I contemplated the age-old argument of analog vs. digital. I decided then that I would play the digital version of this album for comparison. This MoFi release is done perfectly, BTW. Awesome sounding reissue, and limited to only 3,000 copies.
My analog system is as follows:
SME 20/2 turntable w/Tri-Planar tonearm and Lyra Kleos cartridge.
Phono preamp is a Parasound JC-3+.
Niagara 7000 Power Conditioner (Amplifier run straight into the wall)
As I began listening to the digital version (Tidal 44.1k) I was shocked at how I really couldn't hear any significant difference from the LP. This had never been the case with any other DAC I owned in the past. I could enjoy the analog and I could enjoy the digital but I never considered the digital to be as good as the analog, UNLESS it came down to comparing an inferior analog source to superior digital source. With the Mytek DACs I owned (Manhattan II and Brooklyn+) I could always hear a clear difference between digital and analog. It wasn't even close. Now with the May DAC3 I finally understand what the fuss is about when using a very high quality DAC. I'm not arguing one format over the other. I have no intention of selling off my analog gear and going full digital, at least not after only one comparison, but my mind was really blown how great the May DAC performed in this test.
After that I listened to several other Tidal streams and completely lost myself in the music. Stevie Wonder Talking Book, Elvis Costello All This Useless Beauty, Flaming Lips American Head, etc. Everything sounded so right through the May. The whole point of this hobby for me is to find the best version of the music possible, and this DAC has greatly increased my joy of music.
One last thing I noticed yesterday was just how QUIET this DAC is. Until you've heard a really quiet component it's really hard to explain it, but it makes a huge difference when a component like this lowers the noise floor so significantly.
Up and onward...