Havelock Wool acoustic panels vs fiberglass/Rockwool


I have recently found a company offering sheep's wool rigid acoustic panels, (https://havelockwool.com) Havelock Wool Company,  and am considering using them vs the the standard fiberglass/rockwool rigid panels for my DIY wall/ceiling absorbers for my new listening room. 

  The wool would seem to be safer at a casual glance and wool is supposed to be a superior sound absorber I believe.  The cost is a little more, but it is not terribly more expensive.

  I would be interested in others opinions on this approach.

Michael

mckinneymike

Choosing the absorbent filler for Acoustic Panels is one consideration to be decided on. Whether it be a Sustainable Substance as a by-product from one Industry or a product produced from a by-product from another Industry is for the individual to choose.

A choice might be made for simply wanting a Natural Material only within the home, or wanting to support an industry promoting by-product usage and being participant in reducing impact in other Industries.

As a rule of thumb, Fibrous Filler produced as a Glass Wool that weighs approx' 35Kg/m3 is documented for having valuable absorption properties for a broad frequency range, this same guideline may transfer to other Fibrous Fillers Materials as well. 

Fabric Covering / Acoustic Fabric Covering are also going to need to be decided on as a Fabric Covering might be the ideal aesthetic, but not be as suitable as a Acoustic Fabric. For either Fabric, choices made will effect the efficiency of the Built Panel. I use a Fire Rated strengthened Paper as my Panel Covers and as a covering for a few other structures produced in the room.

Placement of the Panel, not just the siting in the Room, but also how the Panels is positioned to the Wall > Ceiling will optimise their use within the space of set up. Hard Back to the Wall > Ceiling is not the optimised, being set up Off the Wall > Ceiling and being better able to Absorb reflected sound from a Hard Surface has merit as a design within a room, but this can mean support legs for a Panel to make this happen. 

I have my best results in my Room when Panels are not hard against the Wall, where the Bulk of the Panels are Floor To Ceiling in the Room Corners, with the Panels creating Triangular Cavity in a Room Corner.

Some places between Speaker and Listener can only have the Panel hard against the Wall, between the Speakers directly in front of the listener and behind the Listening Position, I have opted for the Hard against the Wall position.

Once when on a Hard Floor, (no soft covering) a Soft Material Temporary Used when using the system tidied up the energies released into the room, a secondary glazing system certainly rattled a lit less on certain tracks. If a Temporary Panels was produced due to the room aesthetic not being made less attractive, such a Panel could be tried on the floor in between the Speaker and Listening Position. 

The Between the Speakers, Behind the Listening Position and Side Wall Absorbent Panels have Diffusion Panels mounted on the Absorbent Panels.

Diffusion Panels can be a feature in a room and be quite attractive, but can be costly.

Alternatively, there is ratio info available to self built Diffusion Panels, which can be a design produced that is noticeably more robust/cheaply produced than many seen. The robust design is easily concealed behind the absorbent panels fabric cover. The Frame of the Absorbent Panels can the designed to enable the Diffusion Panel to be Rigidly Attached and have Fibrous Filler put behind it.  

Not limiting oneself to how a Panel Set Up can look in the Room will get the most valuable results. Some Panels in a living space might be best if designed for a Temporary use and easily removed / reinstated by design, the Dimension may be one that is making it easy to conceal the Panel behind another furnishing when not being used.

Additionally, one design for a room that is immediately able to be put in place is for if inanimate object are placed in the Listening Space. Ornaments in a room, Doors on a Display Case, can be effected by energies transferred through sound being produced, sitting Ornaments on a damping materials such as a small pad of Anti-slip Mat or a few 1/2 Pea Size BluTak Pads will really tame these for producing anergy that is audible. A tiny ball of BluTak on a Cabinet Doors Corners is able to tame resonance being created, which can be audible. 

@mckinneymike 

Might be a good sound barrier but wool is quite flammable and fumes from it burning are highly toxic. Not sure what an insurance company might think of it. There are some safety reasons why we use rock wool, sheet rock and other such things in construction. Just my 2c worth. Give you something to worry about.

There is some white insulation that I've seen and had that is not glass wool nor rock wool, no itch to it when using. Can't remember who made it but seems like Dow Corning? Bought at Menards or Home Depot, many years ago. I always thought double drywall and good insulation (any kind?) was the "go to" for a listening room. I know lots of things change over the years and more is learned and developed all the time. 

@billpete 

This is a stand alone structure away from our home, so the wool risks of off gassing if it caught fire are not of much concern.  The concern I have is breathing in fiberglass particles over the years that might be recirculated thru the HVAC system.

  I thought about doubling up the drywall, but have decided to just go with 5/8" on all walls/ceiling surfaces for this first incarnation.  This space is still an unknown as to whether it will sound good, given its steeply sloped attic ceilings.  I just set all of the recessed LED ceiling light power supply boxes today in the main listening room.  I will work on the bathroom and record cleaning area lighting tomorrow morning.  

  I still have 2 more dedicated 10 gauge runs to my source/preamp rack area.  I have two 10 gauge 20 amp dedicated lines wired on the front wall for mono amps. 

  Progressing slower than I hoped, but I enjoy this type of work.  Just wish I had more time to devote to it :)  Hoping to have HVAC ducts set in a week or so and then getting the sheetrock contractor here soon after that.  

@mckinneymike 

I understand. I'm sure you'll end up very happy with it. Just have to get used to the sheep smell. :) Might want some diffusers or some kind of sound treatments up in the A frame area. I'm no expert, that's for sure. Lots of good advice here. I hope it meets all your expectations. I don't think I'll ever get my sound room, just have to adapt my home office space. It's a work in progress, may never end but it's good enough to enjoy music in nearly every day. I also plan to get the dedicated circuits in place before I'm done. Did it in our other house before moving here. No more moves for me. Too old to do it again, Enjoy.

 

@billpete 

 

I am 68 so I get the too old to do it again!  I am not as fast as I used to be for sure.  

  Once I get the room done I plan on building a couple of QRD's for the back wall to see what it does for the sound.  I have planned a pair of these 48" wide and 72" tall by 12" deep.  QR Dude software says that these 43 -1" wide wells should give me a primary diffusion frequency of 550Hz and scatter frequency down to 275Hz.  CNC will do all of the slots for tops and bottoms.  Always wanted to see just what impact a pair of these larger/deeper QRD’s have to offer! 

  I am going to pop for some much better electronics if the room is worthy of the expense.  If so I want this to be my final system!  I might even retire at some point if it sounds as I hope, but I still love working!