I wrote a post, with a thank you to Millercarbon, Geofffkait and others, for comments - just what I look for in Audiogon debate, making me revise my intitial ideas - but it seems it didn't appear here. Anyway, short version, I will certainly look out for too many variables, and I probably will shy away from teleportation too!
Comparing systems through phone recordings
Dear Audiogon friends,
Consider how convenient it would be, if we could exchange sound clips, recordings of how our systems sound in our room, on the web. At Audiogon I get audio friends and contacts whose systems I would love to hear, but they live miles away, or even halfway around the world. The chance that I can come and listen to their system "live" in their listening room is close to zero. So what about, exchanging recordings, instead?
Ten or five years ago, I would have said, forget it, it cannot be done.The drawbacks were too large. Now? I am no longer so sure. Mobile phone technology has advanced. True, I maybe cannot hear the finer nuances of a stereo setup and how it interacts with the room, in a "lowly" mobile phone recording, but I can hear some main characteristics. For example, how my speakers sound compared to my friend’s speakers.
I have tested this concept a bit with other A-goners, using their mobiles to record the same track, playing in their room, recording from their listening position. The results are interesting. They do show differences, even with the limited recording capability, poor mic's, lowgrade file formats, etc.
Anyone else who has tried this?
Consider how convenient it would be, if we could exchange sound clips, recordings of how our systems sound in our room, on the web. At Audiogon I get audio friends and contacts whose systems I would love to hear, but they live miles away, or even halfway around the world. The chance that I can come and listen to their system "live" in their listening room is close to zero. So what about, exchanging recordings, instead?
Ten or five years ago, I would have said, forget it, it cannot be done.The drawbacks were too large. Now? I am no longer so sure. Mobile phone technology has advanced. True, I maybe cannot hear the finer nuances of a stereo setup and how it interacts with the room, in a "lowly" mobile phone recording, but I can hear some main characteristics. For example, how my speakers sound compared to my friend’s speakers.
I have tested this concept a bit with other A-goners, using their mobiles to record the same track, playing in their room, recording from their listening position. The results are interesting. They do show differences, even with the limited recording capability, poor mic's, lowgrade file formats, etc.
Anyone else who has tried this?
- ...
- 32 posts total
Nearfield listening is another variable. My friend’s system is tuned to nearfield listening. We’ve exchanged recordings, but he says its difficult to compare, since our speaker systems are so differently designed, his for nearfield, mine for all-room listening. Good point, a challenge, but I dont think the barrier is insurmountable. |
The call recording applications can easily retrieve data as evidence or just to save time and talk dissertation writers
. The price of applications such as call recorders varies by platform and functionality. |
| Post removed |
around the world. The chance that I can come and listen to their system "live" in their listening room is close to zer
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Folks here believe I can not detect at least some semblance of how a speaker sounds via YT upload.s Sure its only a bare idea of how a particular speaker sounds,, but its enough for me to detect if I will like it or not. Which is why I record my vids now witha close up on the speaker,, this way folks can hear it at close range and make a better guess. I can actually hear how a speaker sounds via YT uploda.s But you have to pay very close attention. Folks here think it can 't be done. Its impossible If Enrico Caruso sang in your shower door closed,,and sang ina Rome opera house,,I'm quite sure you'd recognize his voice as same tenor Does not always work, as I was very impressed with Voxativ on YT so, ordereda pair,,, sold them off cheap same day. Does not always work. Not sure what went wrong on the Vox mistake, Sure sounded fantastic in the Vid,. Of course it was another model in the YT vid vs the one I purchased. Anyway, how my wide bands sound in my YT vids, sound near exact as in my listening room. If you don't like the way my wide band sounds in my YT vids, then don't buy the speaker. As you will make a mistake. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2XeDQ7S4dM |
- 32 posts total