Cartridge recommedations


Hi

I ordered a Music Hall Classic turntable this week and want to upgrade the Spirit cartridge it comes with.

I am on a tight budget and have narrowed down some pick's.

1- Rega ania

2- Dynovector 10x5

3- Ortofon Quintet bronze

4-Audio technia  AT-33sa

5-Hana sl

At present I have a Sound smith othello mounted on a Sota comet turntable I really like.

I have a Feszel SS-4772  tube amp with KT-88 tubes

I also have a Jolida jd1 phono stage I can use on an mc cart.

These will run into a pair of Megnapan MG-1s I rebuildt last year

Any help is greatly accepted.

Thanks

Greg

 

gregaba

Hello,

The good thing is these carts are all a little laid back. The Dynavecktor 10x5 mk2 comes in low and high output. The low is used like a typical MC cart and the high is used as a MM cart. I have the low output and it is great. A friend of mine had the Hana SL and said it was the best $750 cart he ever had. In fact he said he would put it against carts that are 3-4x more expensive. He now has a $4000 cart and that is the only reason he sold it. I think think the Hana SL is the cart for you because none of the other carts have this many great reviews. I have the Quintet Black by Ortifon and the Shibata stylus on a Mark Levenson 5105 tt is a PITA to set up, but once dialed in it’s amazing once it’s dialed in.  The Ania is a great cart but a little on the high side of price that is better for the Rega tt due to the easy setup because of the third Head space screw. The Ania and the Ania pro are great on a Rega P6 or P8. I wish the Ortifon came with the same stylus as the Cadenza series but it doesn’t. So I say skip it. I did install a Dynavecktor 20x on a VPI prime with unipivot arm and it was great. So bottom line. If you want to use a MM setting on your phono stage go with Dynavecktor 10x5 mk2 high output. If you want to go with the MC setting go with the Hana SL. I hope this helps. 

Hi Greg,

I have a Hana SL on my VPI Scout (unipivot arm) and absolutely love it. I did an a/b comparison when I had the Nagaoka MP300 and the Hana beat it in my opinion. The Hana had a larger soundstage and  seemed more rhythmic than the Nagaoka. I can’t comment on the comparison with Dynavector. 
 

Best of luck on your journey, it’s a lot of fun!

I want to thank everyone for your reply's. I still havn't made a decision and am not sure what will meet my expection's.

I read all the reviews on carts that i can find and some of them don't really say much. I was really surprised about the review of the AT carts in Sterophile. I was all ways under the impression they were a entry level cart and as soon as you could you up graded them.

Well the search continues.

Greg

I went from a Hana SH (HOMC) to an Audio Technica AT33SA (LOMC).

I like the AT better.

Think Long Now.

I prefer wide channel separation, combined with tight channel balance, which provides terrific imaging. IOW, use that to narrow the list. Then, does it sound good???

You have tools and skills for alignment?

Advanced Stylus Shape’s last longer, thus not much more costly over time.

Cantilever no stiffer than Boron (they get dangerously brittle).

Single Arm: Changeable Headshells. Perhaps a headshell allowing Azimuth Adjustment.

Better yet, slightly larger TT with two tonearms ready to go instantly in any listening session, i.e. Favorite on Main arm (could be fixed cartridge); 2nd arm (changable headshell) for: alternates, perhaps mono, 2nd favorite MC or MM elliptical stereo iow any other on second arm.

A SUT with two inputs (now or future), optional loading/x factors, and Pass for MM

....................................

Cartridges’s I have owned anf kept in order of preference. Newer versions exist of some.

MC

AT33PTGII, my first MC, ML stylus on Boron, terrific at everything, Chamber to Santana

Goldring, Eroica LO MC Unique Gyger II line contact stylus. A bit less separation which can be good for some content, i.e. Bill Evans at Village Vanguard.

 

MM

AT440ML, ML Stylus on aluminum, just beats my Shure

Shure V15Vxmr body with replacement Jico Shibata on Boron, with brush (not damped). Grace F9E (my close friend’s favorite MM, sounds great). Shure M97xe, elliptical on aluminum with damped brush deals with warps https://www.shure.com/en-EU/products/dj-phono/m97xe Mono: Grado Elliptical