Matching Speakers to amp


I currently own a PSA Stellar 300 paired with Focal Aria 926. I just picked up a used pair of Quad S-5 and I will be comparing the sound. I am not good a using technical specs to compare so I could use some help if anyone has the time to take a look at the amp & speaker specs below and give me some feedback I would greatly appreciate.
The basic question is: from a specification standpoint which speaker pairs up with the Stellar 300 best?


Stellar 300
Gain30.5dB +/-0.5dB Sensitivity for rated output power1.01V Noise1kHz@300 Watts <-100dB Input impedance S300Unbalanced 50KΩ
Balanced 100KΩ Input impedance M700Unbalanced 50KΩ
Balanced 100KΩ Output Impedance50Hz, 2.8VRMS <0.007Ω Damping factor50Hz. 2.8VRMS
8Ω >1100
4Ω >550 Frequency Response@2.8VRMS
10Hz – 20KHz +/- 0.5dB
10Hz – 50KHz +0.1/-3.0dB
Output PowerBoth channels driven 120vac mains, 1kHz, 1% THD 8Ω140W minimum 4Ω300W minimum 2Ω Stable for musical transients

Quad S-5
General description 3-way floorstanding speaker
Enclosure type ABR
Transducer complement 3-way ABR 165mm x3 Bass driver 165mm Woven Carbon fibre Cone x2
Midrange driver 125mm Woven Carbon fibre Cone Treble driver 12 x 45 mm
True Ribbon Sensitivity (2.83V @ 1m) 90dB
Recommended amplifier power 25-175W Peak SPL 112dB
Nominal impedance 6Ω
Minimum impedance 3.2Ω
Frequency response (+/-3dB) 42Hz ~ 23kHz Bass extension (-6dB) 35Hz Crossover frequency 570Hz & 3.2kHz

Focal 926
Speaker driversTwo 61/2" (16.5cm) Flax bass61/2" (16.5cm) Flax midrange1" (25mm) Al/Mg TNF inverted dome tweeterFrequency response (+/- 3dB)45Hz - 28kHzLow
frequency point - 6 dB37HzSensitivity (2.83V / 1m)91.5dBNominal impedance8 OhmsMinimum impedance2.9 OhmsRecommended amplifier power40 - 250WCrossover frequency290Hz / 2400Hz











jbuhl

Showing 9 responses by georgehifi

Yeah, I’m not overly impressed with them after seeing what those monoblocks models were, and it wasn’t mentioned in advertising that they were just bridged stereo’s. But the stereo one we heard did sound "ok", on old reasonably hard to drive Infinity’s.

Cheers George
Odyssey Khartago on eBay with larger upgraded power supply, current bid $500.


Consider a Odyssey Khartago stereo amp used. These pop up for $600 occasionally.

These could also be good, as I believe they also use bi-polar output transistors as well and decent power supply to get some current flowing.

But there’s a ? for me on the mono blocks, from couple of models I saw that came through, they were just stereo amps that were bridged.
+More watts
-More distortion
-Less damping factor
-less stable into low impedance’s.

Cheers George
auxinput
I would think that you would want as hefty of a power supply as you could in the amp.
That’s a given, along with bjt’s to back the power supply for good current into low impedances. But as he said he’s looking at " $500-600 level" maybe old JC Parasound poweramps with a $49 Schiit Sys for the pre.
This could do. or an early HCA-2200
https://www.audiogon.com/listings/lis90c17-parasound-2250-solid-state

Cheers George
The Parasound A23 above that George recommended could be nice, but it's only 125 watts per channel.

Yes but the speakers are both over 90db so that 125w @ 8ohm is fine and being John Curl design with BJT output you can bet it no slouch into low impedance's. 
It actually puts out 150w into 8ohm test here in this review and bech test.
http://i.nextmedia.com.au/Assets/Parasound_P5_Preamp_A23_Power_Amp_Review_Test_lores.pdf

Cheers George
George. That old parasound will crumble in camparison to the newer hypex and icepower amps...
Not when they load gets to around 2ohms like with the OP’s two speakers do , that’s where Class-D’s Achilles heel is, they start s**ting themselves below <4ohms.

Cheers George
so I now need to search for an integrated amp around the $500 to $600 range to push these things.
I don’t know the used prices in the US a used John Curl designed Parasound Halo Integrated, it will try to push those low impedance’s in the bass (for an integrated), and I think it has a dac and phono stage in it as well.
https://www.stereophile.com/content/parasound-halo-integrated-integrated-amplifier

These may also be good but you need a preamp, maybe a Schiit Sys $49 will do.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/PARASOUND-HALO-A23-STEREO-POWER-AMPLIFIER-IN-SILVER-COLOR-2/283016082021?ha...

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Parasound-Halo-A23-Amplifier-in-Silver-Excellent-Condition/152948492181?has...

http://www.schiit.com/products/sys


Cheers George


Your Dynaudio 160 have never had an impedance graph done on them, but the 140’s do which is the same family. And yes they are far more easier to drive than the Focals or the Quads of the OP's.

https://www.stereophile.com/images/archivesart/506140FIG1.jpg

Cheers George
johnkent316 posts07-06-2018 9:56pmGeorgehifi is totally incorrect with his response.

I have dynaudio focus 160s being driven by a stellar s300

I understand, you love your amp and are sticking up for it.

But like I said into the OP’s speakers " it will work into them and probably sound fine." But may not perform at their best. 

But your speaker may not have the loading that the OP’s do. (I will try to find it for you.)

I’m just pointing out the tested/measured specs behind it with the OP’s two speakers.

Cheers George
jbuhl
The basic question is: from a specification standpoint which speaker pairs up with the Stellar 300 best?

Sorry, but to me neither speaker will be at their best with the Stellar, it will work into them and probably sound fine, but probably not extract the best from either. >2ohm loads are not Class-D’s forte.

I don’t think big wattage is the answer here as both speakers are over 90db, a 50-100w amp will do, the issue is the amp needs to supply good current into the low bass load as seen by it (below) to keep it from becoming a tone control.

The Quad S5 has a demanding load in the low bass.
As measured by Keith Howard of HiFi News:
" EPDR (equivalent peak dissipation resistance) to fall to a minimum of 1.4ohm at 111Hz, making the S_5 a more than a typically testing load for this size and class of floor stander "

The Focal Aria 962 is also a hard load in the bass as can be seen by this graph from 80hz to 300hz. 2.8ohms and also a -55 degree phase shift, which equates to a EPDR well below 2ohms
https://www.stereophile.com/images/1114FA936fig1.jpg

A Class-D, Tube or Mosfet is not my first choice of amp for loads like these to get the most out of the low bass of these two speakers.
I would prefer to see a linear amp with lots of bi-polar (BJT) output devices and big power supplies, to push current into that bass to keep it under control and flat without becoming a tone control..

Cheers George