People who don't have experienced actual concert (classic, jazz, pop, whatever) usually say that analog (vinyl) is better or true to the music. I know why. Except some cases of very high end analog system and LPs with highest quality, most analog systems give soft sound rather than sharp sound (this sharp sound is only available from real concerts). So, no-concet-experience-people might think the soft sound is musical. Oh, poor people! I cannot talk any more of audio/music listening with the poor people.
CD is absolutely better than LP. This is what Herbert von Karajan said many decades ago!