Vinyl, no question. It's what I actually look forward to actively listening to. Streaming is awesome for when I want music in the background during my day. My CD player has been collecting dust for about five years now, not sure why it's even in my rack.
I think the amount of hype regarding the curation/care of records is completely overblown, and for me it's part of the magic. Oh no, I have to actively engage with physical media! Next you're going to tell me I have to turn the pages of a book (remember those?)! :)